[CMC] Re: Re:: IOP-2 Agenda - CCSDS Presentation

Mon Nov 17 02:30:23 EST 2008

Adrian,

In addition, I will a little bit modify the legend of
solid line "staffing" to "requirements and staffing".

Thanks,
Narita

----- Original Message -----
$BAw?.<T!'(B"Narita, Kaneaki" <narita.kaneaki at jaxa.jp>
$B08 at h!'(BAdrian J. Hooke <adrian.j.hooke at jpl.nasa.gov>
$B#C#C!'(BCCSDS Management Council <cmc at mailman.ccsds.org>, narita.kaneaki at jaxa.jp
$BAw?.F|;~!'(BMon, 17 Nov 2008 16:14:32 +0900 (JST)
$B7oL>!'(BRe: Re:: IOP-2 Agenda - CCSDS Presentation

> Adrian,
> Sorry, me delay of response. I'm working with spam
> mail rescue works.
> Thank you so much for your work about page 7.
> It looks good for me. I will incorporate your idea
> and new figure by half page wide restriction on page 7.
> I also agree to combine ISECG and GES in one circle
> (other CMC member pointed out same comment).
> Let me explain my one comment on your proposal "multilateral
> programs". My idea is the program will be generated
> throughout ISECG and/or ILN future. Therefore, I would 
> like to keep my original wording without "other".
> For the dotted line (requirements) on your proposal,
> the granularity will be the different for IOAG, CCSDS
> and SFCG. 
> w/IOAG: ISECG, ILN and Program will recognize the IOAG
> the prime point of contact to proceed their comms. &
> navigation architecture to respective standardization
> requirements.
> w/CCSDS: under IOAG advisory, individual requirements
> for necessary standardization will be coordinated with
> them.
> w/SFCG: Spectrum matter will be taking care of with them.
> I hope we are on the same page. 
> I will distribute Version-2, asap.
> I appreciate your continous support and suggestion.
> Best Regards,
> Narita
> ----- Original Message -----
> $BAw?.<T!'(BAdrian J. Hooke <adrian.j.hooke at jpl.nasa.gov>
> $B08 at h!'(Bnarita.kaneaki <narita.kaneaki at jaxa.jp>
> $B#C#C!'(BCCSDS Management Council <cmc at mailman.ccsds.org>
> $BAw?.F|;~!'(BFri, 14 Nov 2008 09:25:23 -0500
> $B7oL>!'(BRe:: IOP-2 Agenda - CCSDS Presentation
> > --=====================_6969968==.ALT
> > Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"; format=flowed
> > At 07:44 AM 11/14/2008, narita.kaneaki wrote:
> > >Based on his feedback, I found that there is inconsistency between 
> > >page 5, first bullet text and page 7 figure.(Draw direct solid line 
> > >between IOAG and GES, ISECG, ILN.)
> > Narita-san:  slide 7 seems to conflict with the consensus of the CMC 
> > that was expressed in Berlin, i.e., that the CCSDS is an independent 
> > organization that takes advice - but not direction - from the IOAG. 
> > Indeed, the very name of the IOAG - "Advisory" - reflects this 
> > relationship; as does the fact that not all CCSDS agencies are 
> > represented on the IOAG.
> > Maybe a more accurate picture might be something like the attached, 
> > which recognizes that the CCSDS derives its requirements from many sources?
> > Best regards
> > Adrian
> > Adrian J. Hooke
> > Chairman, CCSDS Engineering Steering Group (CESG) 
> > --=====================_6969968==.ALT
> > Content-Type: text/html; charset="us-ascii"
> > <html>
> > <body>
> > <font color="#0000FF">At 07:44 AM 11/14/2008, narita.kaneaki wrote:<br>
> > </font><blockquote type=cite class=cite cite="">
> > <font size=2 color="#0000FF">Based on his feedback, I found that there is
> > inconsistency between page 5, first bullet text and page 7 figure.(Draw
> > direct solid line between IOAG and GES, ISECG,
> > ILN.)</font><font size=2></font></blockquote><br>
> > Narita-san:&nbsp; slide 7 seems to conflict with the consensus of the CMC
> > that was expressed in Berlin, i.e., that the CCSDS is an independent
> > organization that takes advice - but not direction - from the IOAG.
> > Indeed, the very name of the IOAG - &quot;Advisory&quot; - reflects this
> > relationship; as does the fact that not all CCSDS agencies are
> > represented on the IOAG.<br><br>
> > Maybe a more accurate picture might be something like the attached, which
> > recognizes that the CCSDS derives its requirements from many
> > sources?<br><br>
> > Best regards<br>
> > Adrian<br>
> > <x-sigsep><p></x-sigsep>
> > <font size=2>Adrian J. Hooke<br>
> > Chairman, CCSDS Engineering Steering Group (CESG)</font></body>
> > </html>
> > --=====================_6969968==.ALT--