[MOIMS] Fw: [CESG] NEW POLL: CESG-R-2005-11-001(MOIMS-SMC WG-R-2005-10-007)- INFORMAL - DRAFT SM&C RED BOOKS

Sun Nov 6 14:00:38 UTC 2005

Mario,

Debi cominciare la review informale a livello ESA.

ciao
nestor

----- Forwarded by Nestor Peccia/esoc/ESA on 06/11/2005 14:58 -----

             "Adrian J. Hooke"                                               
             <adrian.j.hooke at jp                                              
             l.nasa.gov>                                                  To 
             Sent by:                   CCSDS Engineering Steering Group -   
             cesg-bounces at mailm         ADs <cesg at mailman.ccsds.org>         
             an.ccsds.org                                                 cc 

                                                                     Subject 
             04/11/2005 23:26           [CESG] NEW POLL:                     
                                        CESG-R-2005-11-001(MOIMS-SMC         
                                        WG-R-2005-10-007)- INFORMAL - DRAFT  
                                        SM&C RED BOOKS                       

ADs and DADS: the MOIMS Spacecraft Monitor and Control Working Group has
requested that the CESG should seek to obtain an early and informal peer
review of the new draft SM&C services. The purpose of this wide peer review
is to identify any "show stoppers" before the SM&C-WG commits further
resources. You will recall that we agreed at the Fall 2005 meeting that in
some cases such an early and wide review is highly desirable.

You are accordingly requested to take two months to disseminate these
documents to a wide audience of potentially interested parties, and to feed
back the results by then responding to the following TWO MONTH POLL:.

http://public.ccsds.org/sites/cwe/cesg/polls/default.aspx

Polls:

1. CESG-R-2005-11-001(MOIMS-SMC WG-R-2005-10-007) INFORMAL REVIEW OF DRAFT
SM&C RED BOOKS

You will need to  click the CWE "Sign In" button located at the top right of
the page and provide your log-in information. Should you require log-in
assistance, please click on "Help" located at the top left of the page.

Responses:
ABSTAIN                  (does not affect my Area)
APPROVE UNCONDITIONALLY
APPROVE WITH CONDITIONS  (state conditions that must be satisfied)
DISAPPROVE WITH COMMENT  (state detailed reasons for disapproval)

Poll Open:  07 November 2005
Poll Close: 07 January  2006
*******************************************************************

CESG-R-2005-11-001(MOIMS-SMC WG-R-2005-10-007) INFORMAL REVIEW OF DRAFT SM&C
RED BOOKS

The CESG,

CONSIDERING that:

1. New SM&C services are being proposed by MOIMS in the form of Draft Red
Books.
2. These new services potentially have far reaching effects.
2. It is highly desirable to gain an early assessment as to whether these new
services will be acceptable to the CCSDS community, to avoid unnecessary
expenditure of MOIMS resources.

and RECOGNIZING that:

1. It has been agreed within CESG that in such cases the Areas will seek an
informal review of the draft documents across a wide segment of the CCSDS
community, to obtain early feedback
2. The Area Directors should therefore personally seek wide expert opinion
before committing to finalization of the Red Books and submission for formal
Agency review.

RESOLVES that since such an informal peer review by a wide audience of Agency
experts has been conducted, the MOIMS Area should incorporate the results of
that review into updated Red Books, at which time the CESG will conduct a
short final review before recommending that the Red Books should be issued
for formal Agency review.

(See attached files:
SM&C Protocol draft 0.6.zip
SM&C Common Services draft 0.3.zip
SM&C Core Services draft 0.4.zip)

*********************************************************************

_______________________________________________
CESG mailing list
CESG at mailman.ccsds.org
http://mailman.ccsds.org/mailman/listinfo/cesg