[Moims-dai] Version with updates to section 6.1.5, drawings and some references

Mon Jun 4 11:41:31 UTC 2018

PS:

In addition 

I would like to remind you that this issue had already been discussed 

several times and was also finally decided. 

The ticketing system clearly tracks and documents this decision with the
statement

of David: DAI 20171107 agrees on the more general approach in this
attachment 

to supporting distributed archiving rather than introducing about
Inner-Outer. 

So I do not understand, why this was later re-openend

after the 8th of May this year and of course why this was not coordinated
with us.

Again, Inner-Outer etc. is a very special form of distribution. If properly
motivated,

it can be positioned as such a special topology of <distribution but not

by substituting the more general form of Distributed Archives with
Distributed

Functional Entities.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------
FernUniversität Hagen                     Phone:  +49-2331-987-304
Prof. Dr.-Ing. Matthias L. Hemmje Fax:        +49-2331-987-4487
Universitätsstrasse 1                        Email:
Matthias.Hemmje at fernuni-hagen.de
D-58097 Hagen, Germany               Web:      http://www.fernuni-hagen.de/
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------

From: MOIMS-DAI <moims-dai-bounces at mailman.ccsds.org> On Behalf Of Prof.
Dr.-Ing. Matthias L. Hemmje
Sent: Montag, 4. Juni 2018 08:23
To: 'MOIMS-Data Archive Interoperability' <moims-dai at mailman.ccsds.org>
Subject: Re: [Moims-dai] Version with updates to section 6.1.5, drawings and
some references

Good Morning, 

I would like to object to these changes related to 6.1.5. in the currently
introduced form

as they are  misusing our original contribution and are misleading w.r.t.
the original 

intentions of adding this section. 

We have been introducing, coordinating and

discussing our contribution for more than two years now.

It was initially based on an change request prepared 

in several workshop activities by the NESTOR communities

in Germany and therefore it is not ok to try to turn it into something 

totally different now.

This new intended contribution is introducing other concepts (inner and

outer OAIS) which are less general than the concept of a distributed 

OAIS with distributed functional  entities. 

The concepts of an inner and an outer OAIS had been 

discussed repeatedly and diversely but NEVER

in relationship to section 6.1.5. 

If they are to be added now, they should 

be added in a different place and with clear motivations and consensus

building beforehand which I have not been aware of.

In the new figures / example provided and the accordingly revised text, 

the inner and outer OAIS are still complete OAIS which was NOT the 

idea of the original contribution of this section related to distributed
OAIS 

with distributed functional entities as we had been discussing a 

distributed OAIS where the functional entities are really distributed

(and therefore each individual contributing archive may not be a complete
OAIS

like many small and medium archives) and only their quasi virtual
integration

produces the complete virtual OAIS.

The concept of inner and outer OAIS is a different one. I am not saying it

could not be added as a separate contribution in some other place but not by
misusing

our contribution in 6.1.5 and making the original intention of the concept
of distributed OAIS 

with distributed functional entities disappear.

Best regards

Matthias Hemmje

----------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------
FernUniversität Hagen                     Phone:  +49-2331-987-304
Prof. Dr.-Ing. Matthias L. Hemmje Fax:        +49-2331-987-4487
Universitätsstrasse 1                        Email:
Matthias.Hemmje at fernuni-hagen.de <mailto:Matthias.Hemmje at fernuni-hagen.de> 
D-58097 Hagen, Germany               Web:      http://www.fernuni-hagen.de/
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------

From: MOIMS-DAI <moims-dai-bounces at mailman.ccsds.org
<mailto:moims-dai-bounces at mailman.ccsds.org> > On Behalf Of Eld Zierau
Sent: Freitag, 1. Juni 2018 16:39
To: moims-dai at mailman.ccsds.org <mailto:moims-dai at mailman.ccsds.org> 
Subject: [Moims-dai] Version with updates to section 6.1.5, drawings and
some references

As promised here is a version based on the document send 25 of April 2018.

It includes suggested changes to

·       Section 6-5 (in accordance with recent updates to issue 135)

·       References in Annex D (in accordance with recent updates to issue
134)

·       All figures are substituted except Figure C-1 (in accordance with
issue 137, 140, 141, 142 and some minor colour changes and consistency in
naming and place of arrow text)

Best regards, Eld

Eld Zierau
IT-konsulent, ph.d.
Digital Preservation Specialist, PhD

Afdelingen for Digital Kulturarv

Digital Cultural heritage 

+4591324690

elzi at kb.dk <mailto:elzi at kb.dk> 

Det Kgl. Bibliotek

Royal Danish Library

Søren Kierkegaards Plads 1

DK-1221 København K

+45 3347 4747

CVR 2898 8842

EAN 5798 000 795297

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mailman.ccsds.org/pipermail/moims-dai/attachments/20180604/68a96309/attachment.html>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: image001.png
Type: image/png
Size: 6924 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://mailman.ccsds.org/pipermail/moims-dai/attachments/20180604/68a96309/attachment.png>