[Moims-dai] Fwd: [MOIMS] [Cesg-all] CMC Resolutions and Actions approved during CCSDS Fall 2016 meeting

Fri Oct 28 10:03:02 UTC 2016

FYI

Sent from my Samsung device

-------- Original message --------
From: Mario.Merri at esa.int 
Date: 28/10/2016  10:50  (GMT+00:00) 
To: moims at mailman.ccsds.org, 	garrett at his.com 
Subject: [MOIMS] [Cesg-all] CMC Resolutions and Actions approved during CCSDS Fall	2016 meeting 

Dear MOIMS leaders,

please find below the CMC Resolutions and
Actions approved during CCSDS Fall 2016 meeting. The relevance for the
MOIMS is as follows:

DAI: 1, 2, 25*

MP&S: none

NAV: 3, 5

SM&C: 6, 23*, Action2 (see word
document, despite the action is on the CCSDS Secretariat the WG should
give a new name to the ZeroMQ book)

TEL: 7.

The item with * have an action associated
that needs to be worked out by the WG.

@DAI: Resolution 25 is what CMC has agreed
which is different from what you proposed, but - I think - it goes in the
same direction. Through that short paper you will have the chance to deliver
to the CMC your vision. My recommendation is to make sure that your vision
fits with the future needs of the space sector. Brigitte and I would like
to be involved in the review/discussion of that paper.

@TEL: I was expecting to see also a resolution
on "inviting space agencies to reconsider their interest in MOIMS/TEL
considering the increasing international cooperation in exploration".
I am enquiring if this was a deliberate decision or it was just forgotten.

Please let me know if you have any questions.

Regards,

__Mario

----- Forwarded by Mario
Merri/esoc/ESA on 28/10/2016 11:19 -----

From:      
 Nestor.Peccia at esa.int

To:      
 "CCSDS Engineering
Steering Group - CESG All" <cesg-all at mailman.ccsds.org>, "CCSDS
Secretariat (secretariat at mailman.ccsds.org)" <secretariat at mailman.ccsds.org>,
"Oliver, Brian\(HQ-CG000\)[Arctic Slope Technical Services, Inc.]"
<brian.oliver at nasa.gov>, "Thomas Gannett" <tomg at aiaa.org>

Cc:      
 "CCSDS Management
Council\(CMC at mailman.ccsds.org\)\(CMC at mailman.ccsds.org\)" <cmc at mailman.ccsds.org>

Date:      
 28/10/2016 09:53

Subject:    
   [Cesg-all] CMC
Resolutions and Actions approved during CCSDS Fall      
 2016 meeting

Sent by:    
   "CESG-All"
<cesg-all-bounces at mailman.ccsds.org>

Dear all, 

Please find attached for your info the set of CMC resolutions and actions
decided during the last joint CESG / CMC meeting held on 25th / 26th Oct
2016 at ASI, Rome. 

These resolutions are avoiding the administrative overhead of handling
dozens of CESG and CMC polls, but it imposes a set of actions to implement
them. 

For the sake of completeness and clarity, you will find below a textual
summary indicating the actions to be completed asap (including some clarifications).
The word file produced by the Secretariat is also attached.

I count on every actionee to proceed accordingly. 

In case of doubts, please contact me. 

ciao 

nestor 

================================= 

Action to be completed by SLS ADs / OPT WG Chairs and Secretariat (B. Oliver)

Resolution 24 

The CMC acknowledges the progress made in the SLS optical communications
working group towards the establishment of blue books for the high photon
efficiency and the low complexity optical standards. CMC welcomes the intention
expressed by the working group to document the high data rate options into
orange books.  The CMC is however concerned about the pace of progress
in the production of such orange books. Due to the lack of agreement on
the structure of the orange book, the CMC has debated the issue and has
concluded on the structure of the orange books that is considered to be
the preferred solution.   

One Orange Book of the NASA Led Option
and 
One Orange Book of the ESA/DLR Led
OptionThe CMC expects
however that the entire working group will work together to create these
orange books. 

Considering the above, the CMC instructs the CESG to implement the CMC
recommendation identified above down to the working group level. It is
understood that none of these orange books can become blue books without
consensus of the CCSDS agencies at all levels of the CCSDS organization
(as is defined by the CCSDS Procedures manual – CCSDS A02.1-Y-4).

Clarification: Create the two OBs Projects. Book Editor for OB1 is
NASA. Book Editor for OB 2 is ESA/DLR. Once created Brian has to set them
as Approved Projects. 

WG Chairs have also to 

1.        Discuss
about the possibility of having two issues (timely separated) of each existing
BB (one issue for high photon efficiency and  one issue for low complexity).
This implies the production of 2 Draft Projects for BB Issue 2

2.        update
the Charter accordingly

Once completed a CMC poll
shall be issued. 

Take Notice: G. Calzolari / G. Mouty, B. Edwards / K. J. Schulz

Action to be completed by SLS RFM Chairs and Secretariat (B. Oliver)

RESOLUTION 10.         

To delete the two bullets from the SLS RFM charter (higher order modulations
for deep space applications and On communications in Emergency communications)

Clarification: RFM WG Chairs to update Charter. Brian Oliver to avoid
an automatic generation of a CMC Poll for approval.

Take Notice: G. Calzolari / G. Mouty, E. Vassallo / D. Lee

Action to be completed by DAI WG Chairs and MOIMS ADs

RESOLUTION 25.        DAI WG Resolution:

CMC acknowledges that in today’s  Data Economy, space systems  generating
and transporting large amounts of relevant data;  be it science (GAIA
is generating 50 GB/day) earth observation (Sentinel-2A generating 1 TB/
h), navigation or telecommunication satellites,  constitute key assets
for the Data industry. 

In this context, standards supporting proper storage and preservation of
data, open access to the space data, merging of data from different sources,
analysis and processing big data and all related processes and mechanisms
are of paramount importance. 

Scientific communities are already for quite some time working nationally
and internationally to define adequate standards for their data, be it
astronomy, planetary exploration or earth observation.

The question is what should the CCSDS organisation do and how should it
position itself in the wake of such space data revolution and  how
could the work done over the years to standardise data storage and archiving
be leveraged at the service of the new paradigms.

In this context, and following the request of the DAI WG to the CMC for
support, CMC would like to encourage the DAI WG to address the following
questions within a short paper to be delivered to CMC by 1 February 2017:

1.        What
is the current DAI roadmap and how does it make a valuable contribution
to the data issue, taking into account what has already been produced including
the overall worldwide efforts in this area? 

2.        Taking
into account that there are dedicated international organisations working
on archiving and merging scientific data, astronomy data, as well as Earth
data, what should be the role of CCSDS in general and that of the DAI WG
in particular? 

3.        Is
the long term data preservation of the housekeeping data properly addressed
in these initiatives? Is there a need for developing this part of the data
preservation? 

4.        In
this context, what would be the next project for the DAI WG in the future,
should resources be available, and how would this project fit with the
current CCSDS reference architecture and work plan?

Clarification:
None. DAI and MOIMS to produce the requested TN.

Take Notice: M. Merri / B. Behal, D. Giaretta / J. Garrett

Actions to be completed by Secretariat (Brian Oliver) on the CWE Projects.

RESOLUTION 1. 

To remove the resource for prototype of CNES for the MOIMS/DAI WG - DEDSL-XML/XSD

Clarification: It is an OB. No need for prototype 1 resources

Take Notice: M. Merri / B. Behal, D. Giaretta / J. Garrett

RESOLUTION 3.        

To cancel the MOIMS/NAV WG Spacecraft Maneuver Message (SMM) Project*  

 Clarification: It is an approved project and has to be deleted.

Take Notice: M. Merri / B. Behal, D. Berry / F. Dreger

RESOLUTION 5.

To include the second prototype for the MOIMS/NAV WG Pointing Request Messages
Book.     

The Prototype two is not a single agency, it is four agencies, NASA, CNES,
JAXA and AGI.                  

Clarification: It is an approved project missing 1 resource. 

Take Notice: M. Merri / B. Behal, D. Berry / F. Dreger

RESOLUTION 6.

To identify CNES as the second prototype of the MOIMS/SM&C Mission
Data product distribution services.          

 Clarification:
It is an approved project missing 1 resource 

Take Notice: M. Merri / B. Behal, D. Smith / S. Cooper

RESOLUTION 7.

To demote the MOIMS/TEL Telerobotics BB to draft project*

 Clarification:
It is an approved project and shall be converted in a draft project. It
shall not appeared anymore in the Resource View

Take Notice: M. Merri / B. Behal 

RESOLUTION 8.

To identify DLR as the second prototyper for SIS/DTN Bundle Security Protocol
(BSP) 

Clarification: It is an approved project  missing 1 resource

Take Notice: K. Scott / T. De Cola, K. Scott / K. Suzuki

RESOLUTION 14.

To approve the SLS/OPT project for the magenta book on atmospheric characterization
and forecasting for the optical link operations. 

Clarification: It is a Draft  project  to be converted in
an " Approved Project".  Add Other (" NCIT (Japan)
in comment field) "  as resource for Editor

Take Notice: G. Calzolari / G. Mouty, B. Edwards / K. J. Schulz

RESOLUTION 15.

To demote the SOIS/WIR High Data Rate Project from Active to Draft project
status. 

 Clarification:
It is an approved project and shall be converted in a draft project. It
shall not appeared anymore in the Resource View

Take Notice: J. Wilmot / ,X. He,  K. Gifford,/ Y. Sheynin

RESOLUTION 17.

 To delete the Magenta Book project on SOIS Subnetwork deterministic network
services 856.0-M.

 Clarification: It is an approved project

Take Notice: J. Wilmot / ,X. He,  G. Rakow / M. Rovati

RESOLUTION 18.         

To delete the SEA/SAWG Application and Support Architecture Magenta Book
project and to approve the Application and Support Architecture Green Book
project. [Check Book Number] 

 Clarification: MB was a draft project and it has already been deleted.
GB is a draft project that has to be upgraded as Approved Project. Add
NASA, ESA as resources for editorship. 

Take Notice: P. Shames / ,H.. takeuchi,  P. Shames

RESOLUTION 23.         

To approve revision of the MOIMS SM&C green book 520.0-G-3 as a new
project. 

Clarification:
Project has to
be created by SM&C WG and added as an approved Project by Brian.
Book editor resource
is ESA 

Take Notice: M. Merri / B. Behal, D. Smith / S. Cooper

Actions to be taken by Secretariat (Tom Gannett)

RESOLUTION 9.

To reconfirm the SLS/RFM 415.1-B-1 - Data Transmission and PN Ranging for
2 GHz CDMA link via Data Relay Satellite book.

Clarification: It is a Book for 5 yesr review to be reconfirmed. Status
to be updated in " Document Status" file.

Take Notice: G. Calzolari / G. Mouty, E. Vassallo / D. Lee

RESOLUTION 11.

To reconfirm the SLS/SLP 133.1-B-2 - CCSDS Encapsulation Service

Clarification: It is a Book for 5 yesr review to be reconfirmed. Status
to be updated in " Document Status" file.

Take Notice: G. Calzolari / G. Mouty, G. Kazz

RESOLUTION 12.        

To reconfirm the SLS/SLP 700.0-G-3 - of AOS GB

Clarification: It is a Book for 5 yesr review to be reconfirmed. Status
to be updated in " Document Status" file.

Take Notice: G. Calzolari / G. Mouty, G. Kazz

RESOLUTION 13.         

To reconfirm the SLS/SLP 200.0-G-6 - of TC GB 

Clarification: It is a Book for 5 yesr review to be reconfirmed. Status
to be updated in " Document Status" file.

Take Notice: G. Calzolari / G. Mouty, G. Kazz

Actions to be taken by Secretariat (Laura Stafford / Brian Oliver)

RESOLUTION 2.

The CMC waived the requirement of 30 days to find a candidate for the MOIMS
DAI Deputy Chair and approved John Garrett (Associate – NASA) as the DAI
Deputy Chair. This resolution recognizes that the deputy chair will not
be funded by CNES after this year. 

Clarification: Please update WG view in CWE by adding John as WG deputy
Chair. 

Take Notice: M. Merri / B. Behal, D. Giaretta / J. Garrett

RESOLUTION 20.

to close and archive the XML SIG and to introduce XML Guidelines as a draft
project in the SEA/SAWG. 

 Clarification: Archive all info of the XML SIG, Update Technical
Organization View in CWE. Draft Project is already defined in SA WG

Take Notice: P. Shames / ,H.. Takeuchi,  P. Shames

RESOLUTION 21.

To name Jonathan Wilmot from NASA as the SOIS Area Director.

 Clarification: please update Technical Organization view in
CWE and add Jonathan in CESG mailingt list 

Take Notice: J. Wilmot / ,X. He 

RESOLUTION 22.

To name He Xiongwen from CNSA as the SOIS Deputy Area Director.

Clarification: please update Technical Organization view in CWE and
add Xiongwen in CESG mailingt list 

Take Notice: J. Wilmot / ,X. He 

Actions to be taken by Secretariat (Tom Gannett / Brian Oliver)

RESOLUTION 16.

To silverize the following SOIS publications: 

CCSDS 871.0-M-1, Spacecraft Onboard Interface Services—Device Access Service
(Magenta Book, Issue 1, March 2013) 

CCSDS 871.1-M-1, Spacecraft Onboard Interface Services—Device Data Pooling
Service (Magenta Book, Issue 1, November 2012)

CCSDS 871.2-M-1, Spacecraft Onboard Interface Services—Device Virtualization
Service (Magenta Book, Issue 1, March 2014) 

CCSDS 871.3-M-1, Spacecraft Onboard Interface Services—Device Enumeration
Service (Magenta Book, Issue 1, October 2014) 

CCSDS 872.0-M-1, Spacecraft Onboard Interface Services—Time Access Service
(Magenta Book, Issue 1, January 2011) 

CCSDS 873.0-M-1, Spacecraft Onboard Interface Services—File and Packet
Store Services (Magenta Book, Issue 1, September 2012)

CCSDS 875.0-M-1, Spacecraft Onboard Interface Services—Message Transfer
Service (Magenta Book, Issue 1, November 2012)

 Clarification: please proceed accordingly and silverize (i.e to
Archive) 

Take Notice: J. Wilmot / ,X. He 

this message and any attachments are intended for
the use of the addressee or addressees only.

The unauthorised disclosure, use, dissemination or copying (either in whole
or in part) of its

content is not permitted.

If you received this message in error, please notify the sender and delete
it from your system.

Emails can be altered and their integrity cannot be guaranteed by the sender.

Please consider the environment before printing this email.

_______________________________________________

CESG-All mailing list

CESG-All at mailman.ccsds.org

https://mailman.ccsds.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/cesg-all

this message and any attachments are intended for the use of the addressee or addressees only.
The unauthorised disclosure, use, dissemination or copying (either in whole or in part) of its
content is not permitted.
If you received this message in error, please notify the sender and delete it from your system.
Emails can be altered and their integrity cannot be guaranteed by the sender.

Please consider the environment before printing this email.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mailman.ccsds.org/pipermail/moims-dai/attachments/20161028/8080086c/attachment.html>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: Resolutions and Action Items.docx
Type: application/octet-stream
Size: 25497 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://mailman.ccsds.org/pipermail/moims-dai/attachments/20161028/8080086c/attachment.obj>