[Css-csts] CSTS Framework draft 0.13 on the web site

[Lassere Francois]

Yves

After reading the last version of the framework document (with the association control state table updated). we think that on that point, there is still something unclear for future document readers : In paragraph 2.4.2 Common procedures (Note page 2-7) we can read the following sentence "The Association procedure does not belong to any class (stateful or stateless)". But in the procedure description the paragraph 4.2.5 is titled "procedure state table" this implies the procedure has some states. In the table the states mentionned are "bound" and "unbound" and, according to the text of the procedure description, these states are the provider states. This is different for the other common procedures of the document (in 4.1.2.2 State transition table : "The state tables specify operation interactions and state transitions for the procedures on the provider side") so this is not true for the Association Control procedure which is specific.  We think it's a little bit confusing. However, after discussion we don't know really the best way to clarify this point. Perhaps we could discuss this question via email or during next teleconference.

Additional comment : Table 2-4-2 (page 2-8) : in this list the Notification procedure is SL (stateless), but in the procedure description (paragraph 4.9) this procedure is described as a stateful procedure.

Best regards.

François and Cyril



-----Message d'origine-----
De : css-csts-bounces at mailman.ccsds.org [mailto:css-csts-bounces at mailman.ccsds.org] De la part de Yves.Doat at esa.int
Envoyé : mardi 20 mai 2008 19:45
À : css-csts at mailman.ccsds.org
Objet : [Css-csts] CSTS Framework draft 0.13 on the web site


Dear all,

During today's teleconference, the participants pointed out that the version 0.13 on the web site seems old. I confirm that the version 0.13 of the Framework Recommendation I uploaded to the web site is an old version.

I just corrected my mistake and I uploaded the correct version ("CSTS Procedures Definition Recommendation 0.13 corrected.doc")

I confirm the two points I mentioned in my previous mail:
   The Association Control procedure was updated to limit its scope to the
   procedure states (unbound & bound). There is an open question with a
   possible solution in the state table to be considered (reaction to an
   incoming unbind when the prime procedure is active). Please have a look to
   the state table in section 4.2.5, rows 3.1 & 3.2.
   The Notification procedure has been updated to be in line with the
   extension approach described in the rest of the document.

I apologise for the time you may have spent trying to find out the discussed changes.

NEW DATE FOR YOUR AGENDA:
      Our next teleconference will take place on the 03.06.2008 starting at 16:00 European time.

Best regards.

Yves


_______________________________________________
Css-csts mailing list
Css-csts at mailman.ccsds.org http://mailman.ccsds.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/css-csts