[CMC] RE: IOP-2 Agenda - SFCG, CCSDS, SIAG Presentations

[Allan, PM (Peter)]

Adrian,

I think the relationship between IOAG and CCSDS needs to be clarified
and agreed by both sides as clearly they are different at the moment.
There does not seem to be agreement even within IOAG, since at the
recent meeting I was very concerned about Badri saying that IOAG tells
CCSDS what to do, so I asked Jim Costrell about this and he said that
was not the case. This ought to be sorted out before the IOP, but I
suspect that will not be.

My position is very clear. Until BNSC is a full member of IOAG, I will
in no way consider committing BNSC resources to any requests coming from
IOAG. To do so would be bad management.

Peter Allan

-----Original Message-----
From: cmc-bounces at mailman.ccsds.org
[mailto:cmc-bounces at mailman.ccsds.org] On Behalf Of Hooke, Adrian J
Sent: 05 November 2008 18:26
To: cmc at mailman.ccsds.org
Subject: [CMC] RE: IOP-2 Agenda - SFCG, CCSDS, SIAG Presentations

CMC Members: as you may know, Mike is currently undergoing surgery. In
his absence, are there any objections to the proposal from NASA
concerning the CCSDS presentation at the second Inter-Operability
Plenary? It certainly appears to contradict the consensus of the CMC
that was expressed during the recent meeting in Berlin, i.e., that the
CCSDS is an independent body and that it should be left to the CMC to
determine who represents the organization to the IOP.

Please respond no later than COB on Friday, 07 November.

Best regards
Adrian Hooke
Chairman, CESG and IOAG Liaison

________________________________________
From: cmc-bounces at mailman.ccsds.org [cmc-bounces at mailman.ccsds.org] On
Behalf Of Costrell, James (HQ-CG000) [James.Costrell at nasa.gov]
Sent: Wednesday, November 05, 2008 12:38 PM
To: Kearney, Mike W. (MSFC-EO01); john.j.rush at nasa.gov;
Paolo.Maldari at esa.int; CCSDS Management Council; edoardo.marelli at esa.int
Cc: sks at istrac.org; Adde, Barbara (HQ-CG000); Costrell, James
(HQ-CG000); Younes, Badri (HQ-CA000); narita.kaneaki; Carbery,    Ron
(HQ-CG000); Klaus-Juergen.Schulz at esa.int; Manfred.Warhaut at esa.int
Subject: [CMC] IOP-2 Agenda - SFCG, CCSDS, SIAG Presentations

On behalf of the IOP-2 Chair Badri Younes/NASA , I am sending the
following message:

"The IOP-2 agenda that has been drafted by the IOAG delegates  is
attached.  As IOP-2 Chair I wish to review this draft agenda with you
before finalizing.

A contingent of IOAG delegates from ASI, CNES, ESA, JAXA, and NASA had
the opportunity to discuss the agenda last week on the margins of
another meeting.  This body selected speakers for the various IOP-2
agenda topics, as indicated in the attachment.  These IOAG delegation
selections followed the following guiding principles:

        1.  spread the presentations among the IOAG delegations
        2.  the IOAG delegations should make the presentations to its
parent body, the IOP.
        3.  the individual IOAG presenters should also be members of the
individual forum (e.g., SFCG) which they will represent.  In this vein
it is expected that the presenters will coordinate their presentations
with the other members of their forum.

Before I finalize the IOP-2 agenda I would like to understand any
different views that you may have as the chairpersons of the subject
bodies, keeping in mind the focus of the IOP.  In the absence of Mike
Kearney, a single coordinated response from the CCSDS Management Council
should be provided.
Badri Younes"

Jim

James A. Costrell
NASA Headquarters
Space Operations Mission Directorate
Deputy Program Manager
Space Communications and Navigation Office Mail Suite 7L70, Office 7L84
300 E St., S.W.
Washington, D.C.  20546
U.S.A.

Phone:  1-202-358-4794
Cell:      1-202-494-9121
Fax:      1-202-358-2830
email:    james.costrell at nasa.gov


_______________________________________________
CMC mailing list
CMC at mailman.ccsds.org
http://mailman.ccsds.org/mailman/listinfo/cmc
-- 
Scanned by iCritical.