[CMC E-Poll Alert] CCSDS Agency-Wide Document Review Notice: CCSDS122.0-R-1, Image Data Compression

[Soula Jean-Marc]

Please find here attached the CNES RIDS to the document :

CCSDS 122.0-R-1.  Image Data Compression.  Red Book.

 <<RID1_CT.txt>> 		 <<RID2_CT.txt>> 		 <<RID3_CT.txt>> 
 <<RID4_CT.txt>> 		 <<RID5_CT.txt>> 		 <<RID6_CT.txt>> 
 <<RID7_CT.txt>> 		 <<RID8_CT.txt>> 		 <<RID9_CT.txt>> 

Best regards

Jean-Marc SOULA
Chargé de Mission Réseaux de Stations
DCT/OP/CM
CNES - 18, Avenue Edouard BELIN
31401 Toulouse Cedex 9 - France
Tel :  (+33) (0)5 612 74647
Fax : (+33) (0)5 612 73135
Email : Jean-Marc.Soula at cnes.fr


-----Message d'origine-----
De : Stephen Harris [mailto:stephen.harris at btas.com <mailto:stephen.harris at btas.com> ] 
Envoyé : jeudi 28 octobre 2004 15:41
À : cmc-exec at mailman.ccsds.org; cesg-all at mailman.ccsds.org; liaisons at mailman.ccsds.org
Objet : [CMC E-Poll Alert] CCSDS Agency-Wide Document Review Notice: CCSDS122.0-R-1, Image Data Compression


Date:	28 October 2004
From:	CCSDS Rapporteur
Subject:  Announcement of Review Opportunity

The following Draft CCSDS Recommended Standard has been placed on-line and is available for Formal Agency Review:

CCSDS 122.0-R-1.  Image Data Compression.  Red Book

Document Description:  This recommendation addresses image data compression, which is applicable to a wide range of space-borne digital data, where the requirement is for a scalable data reduction, including the option to use lossy compression, which allows some loss of fidelity in the process of data compression and decompression.

The due date for receipt of review comments by the Review Coordinators is 2004-12-1.  More information is available at the Web site identified below.

The review document in Portable Document Format (.pdf), and associated review materials may be accessed at the following location:

http://www.ccsds.org/CCSDS/review/index.html <http://www.ccsds.org/CCSDS/review/index.html> 

HTML RID forms available for NASA Center reviewers automatically forward review comments to the respective Center Coordinator.


_______________________________________________
CMC-exec mailing list
CMC-exec at mailman.ccsds.org http://mailman.ccsds.org/mailman/listinfo/cmc-exec <http://mailman.ccsds.org/mailman/listinfo/cmc-exec> 
-------------- next part --------------
                    REVIEW ITEM DISPOSITION (RID):
                    RED BOOK RID INITIATION FORM

AGENCY RID NUMBER:
SUBMITTING ORGANIZATION (Agency, Center):
------------------------------------------------------------------
REVIEWER'S NAME:   THIEBAUT	
CODE:              
E-MAIL ADDRESS:    carole.thiebaut at cnes.fr
TELEPHONE:       00 33 561 283 404
------------------------------------------------------------------
DOCUMENT NUMBER:   CCSDS 122.0-R-1        Red Book, Issue 1
DOCUMENT NAME:     Image Data Compression
DATE ISSUED:       August 2004
PAGE NUMBER:   4-5                PARAGRAPH NUMBER:  4.2
RID SHORT TITLE:   Figure 4-3 title
------------------------------------------------------------------
_____ APPROVE (MEMBER)   _____ CONCUR (OBSERVER)   __x__ COMMENTS

DESCRIPTION OF REQUESTED CHANGE:  (Use From: "..." To "..." format)
 From "Overview of Header Structure When all parts are included" 
to  "Overview of Segment Header Structure When all parts are included" 






------------------------------------------------------------------
CATEGORY OF REQUESTED CHANGE:
     Technical Fact ___    Recommended ___    Editorial _x_
NOTES:
TECHNICAL FACT:  Major technical change of sufficient magnitude as to
 render the Recommendation inaccurate and unacceptable if not
 corrected.  (Supporting analysis/rationale is essential.)
RECOMMENDED:  Change of a nature that would, if incorporated, produce
 a marked improvement in document quality and acceptance.
EDITORIAL:  Typographical or other factual error needing correction.
 (This type of change will be made without feedback to submitter.)
------------------------------------------------------------------
SUPPORTING ANALYSIS:





------------------------------------------------------------------
DISPOSITION:
-------------- next part --------------
                    REVIEW ITEM DISPOSITION (RID):
                    RED BOOK RID INITIATION FORM

AGENCY RID NUMBER:
SUBMITTING ORGANIZATION (Agency, Center):
------------------------------------------------------------------
REVIEWER'S NAME:   THIEBAUT	
CODE:              
E-MAIL ADDRESS:    carole.thiebaut at cnes.fr
TELEPHONE:       00 33 561 283 404
------------------------------------------------------------------
DOCUMENT NUMBER:   CCSDS 122.0-R-1        Red Book, Issue 1
DOCUMENT NAME:     Image Data Compression
DATE ISSUED:       August 2004
PAGE NUMBER:   4-7                PARAGRAPH NUMBER:  4.2.1
RID SHORT TITLE:  reference to [2] 
------------------------------------------------------------------
_____ APPROVE (MEMBER)   _____ CONCUR (OBSERVER)   __x__ COMMENTS

DESCRIPTION OF REQUESTED CHANGE:  (Use From: "..." To "..." format)
 From "Absolute segment counting can be implemented using the CCSDS packet transport scheme in [2]" 
to  "Absolute segment counting can be implemented using the CCSDS packet transport scheme as described in [2]" 






------------------------------------------------------------------
CATEGORY OF REQUESTED CHANGE:
     Technical Fact ___    Recommended __    Editorial _x_
NOTES:
TECHNICAL FACT:  Major technical change of sufficient magnitude as to
 render the Recommendation inaccurate and unacceptable if not
 corrected.  (Supporting analysis/rationale is essential.)
RECOMMENDED:  Change of a nature that would, if incorporated, produce
 a marked improvement in document quality and acceptance.
EDITORIAL:  Typographical or other factual error needing correction.
 (This type of change will be made without feedback to submitter.)
------------------------------------------------------------------
SUPPORTING ANALYSIS:





------------------------------------------------------------------
DISPOSITION:
-------------- next part --------------
                    REVIEW ITEM DISPOSITION (RID):
                    RED BOOK RID INITIATION FORM

AGENCY RID NUMBER:
SUBMITTING ORGANIZATION (Agency, Center):
------------------------------------------------------------------
REVIEWER'S NAME:   THIEBAUT	
CODE:              
E-MAIL ADDRESS:    carole.thiebaut at cnes.fr
TELEPHONE:       00 33 561 283 404
------------------------------------------------------------------
DOCUMENT NUMBER:   CCSDS 122.0-R-1        Red Book, Issue 1
DOCUMENT NAME:     Image Data Compression
DATE ISSUED:       August 2004
PAGE NUMBER:   4-8                PARAGRAPH NUMBER:  4.2.2
RID SHORT TITLE:  Figure and Table 4-5
------------------------------------------------------------------
_____ APPROVE (MEMBER)   _____ CONCUR (OBSERVER)   __x__ COMMENTS

DESCRIPTION OF REQUESTED CHANGE:  (Use From: "..." To "..." format)
5 bits required for BitPlaneStop in Figure 4-5 instead of 4.
2 bits required for StageStop in Figure 4-5 instead of 3.
0 in column Details for the Field 'Reserved' (also in Table 4-6)




------------------------------------------------------------------
CATEGORY OF REQUESTED CHANGE:
     Technical Fact _x_    Recommended ___    Editorial ___
NOTES:
TECHNICAL FACT:  Major technical change of sufficient magnitude as to
 render the Recommendation inaccurate and unacceptable if not
 corrected.  (Supporting analysis/rationale is essential.)
RECOMMENDED:  Change of a nature that would, if incorporated, produce
 a marked improvement in document quality and acceptance.
EDITORIAL:  Typographical or other factual error needing correction.
 (This type of change will be made without feedback to submitter.)
------------------------------------------------------------------
SUPPORTING ANALYSIS:





------------------------------------------------------------------
DISPOSITION:
-------------- next part --------------
                    REVIEW ITEM DISPOSITION (RID):
                    RED BOOK RID INITIATION FORM

AGENCY RID NUMBER:
SUBMITTING ORGANIZATION (Agency, Center):
------------------------------------------------------------------
REVIEWER'S NAME:   THIEBAUT	
CODE:              
E-MAIL ADDRESS:    carole.thiebaut at cnes.fr
TELEPHONE:       00 33 561 283 404
------------------------------------------------------------------
DOCUMENT NUMBER:   CCSDS 122.0-R-1        Red Book, Issue 1
DOCUMENT NAME:     Image Data Compression
DATE ISSUED:       August 2004
PAGE NUMBER:   4-9                PARAGRAPH NUMBER:  4.2.2
RID SHORT TITLE: 
------------------------------------------------------------------
_____ APPROVE (MEMBER)   _____ CONCUR (OBSERVER)   __x__ COMMENTS

DESCRIPTION OF REQUESTED CHANGE:  (Use From: "..." To "..." format)
From" (according to the specified values of DCStop, SegStop, StageStop)"
to "(according to the specified values of DCStop, BitPlaneStop, StageStop)"

------------------------------------------------------------------
CATEGORY OF REQUESTED CHANGE:
     Technical Fact _x_    Recommended ___    Editorial ___
NOTES:
TECHNICAL FACT:  Major technical change of sufficient magnitude as to
 render the Recommendation inaccurate and unacceptable if not
 corrected.  (Supporting analysis/rationale is essential.)
RECOMMENDED:  Change of a nature that would, if incorporated, produce
 a marked improvement in document quality and acceptance.
EDITORIAL:  Typographical or other factual error needing correction.
 (This type of change will be made without feedback to submitter.)
------------------------------------------------------------------
SUPPORTING ANALYSIS:





------------------------------------------------------------------
DISPOSITION:
-------------- next part --------------
                    REVIEW ITEM DISPOSITION (RID):
                    RED BOOK RID INITIATION FORM

AGENCY RID NUMBER:
SUBMITTING ORGANIZATION (Agency, Center):
------------------------------------------------------------------
REVIEWER'S NAME:   THIEBAUT	
CODE:              
E-MAIL ADDRESS:    carole.thiebaut at cnes.fr
TELEPHONE:       00 33 561 283 404
------------------------------------------------------------------
DOCUMENT NUMBER:   CCSDS 122.0-R-1        Red Book, Issue 1
DOCUMENT NAME:     Image Data Compression
DATE ISSUED:       August 2004
PAGE NUMBER:   4-11                PARAGRAPH NUMBER:  4.2.4
RID SHORT TITLE: Figure and Table 4-7
------------------------------------------------------------------
_____ APPROVE (MEMBER)   _____ CONCUR (OBSERVER)   __x__ COMMENTS

DESCRIPTION OF REQUESTED CHANGE:  (Use From: "..." To "..." format)
One Reserved bit in Figure 4-7 and 2 in the Table 4-7.


------------------------------------------------------------------
CATEGORY OF REQUESTED CHANGE:
     Technical Fact _x_    Recommended ___    Editorial ___
NOTES:
TECHNICAL FACT:  Major technical change of sufficient magnitude as to
 render the Recommendation inaccurate and unacceptable if not
 corrected.  (Supporting analysis/rationale is essential.)
RECOMMENDED:  Change of a nature that would, if incorporated, produce
 a marked improvement in document quality and acceptance.
EDITORIAL:  Typographical or other factual error needing correction.
 (This type of change will be made without feedback to submitter.)
------------------------------------------------------------------
SUPPORTING ANALYSIS:





------------------------------------------------------------------
DISPOSITION:
-------------- next part --------------
                    REVIEW ITEM DISPOSITION (RID):
                    RED BOOK RID INITIATION FORM

AGENCY RID NUMBER:
SUBMITTING ORGANIZATION (Agency, Center):
------------------------------------------------------------------
REVIEWER'S NAME:   THIEBAUT	
CODE:              
E-MAIL ADDRESS:    carole.thiebaut at cnes.fr
TELEPHONE:       00 33 561 283 404
------------------------------------------------------------------
DOCUMENT NUMBER:   CCSDS 122.0-R-1        Red Book, Issue 1
DOCUMENT NAME:     Image Data Compression
DATE ISSUED:       August 2004
PAGE NUMBER:   4-12                PARAGRAPH NUMBER:  4.3
RID SHORT TITLE: Table 4-8
------------------------------------------------------------------
_____ APPROVE (MEMBER)   _____ CONCUR (OBSERVER)   __x__ COMMENTS

DESCRIPTION OF REQUESTED CHANGE:  (Use From: "..." To "..." format)
add "if BitDepthAC =0, q'=0" in Table 4-8

------------------------------------------------------------------
CATEGORY OF REQUESTED CHANGE:
     Technical Fact _x_    Recommended ___    Editorial ___
NOTES:
TECHNICAL FACT:  Major technical change of sufficient magnitude as to
 render the Recommendation inaccurate and unacceptable if not
 corrected.  (Supporting analysis/rationale is essential.)
RECOMMENDED:  Change of a nature that would, if incorporated, produce
 a marked improvement in document quality and acceptance.
EDITORIAL:  Typographical or other factual error needing correction.
 (This type of change will be made without feedback to submitter.)
------------------------------------------------------------------
SUPPORTING ANALYSIS:





------------------------------------------------------------------
DISPOSITION:
-------------- next part --------------
                    REVIEW ITEM DISPOSITION (RID):
                    RED BOOK RID INITIATION FORM

AGENCY RID NUMBER:
SUBMITTING ORGANIZATION (Agency, Center):
------------------------------------------------------------------
REVIEWER'S NAME:   THIEBAUT	
CODE:              
E-MAIL ADDRESS:    carole.thiebaut at cnes.fr
TELEPHONE:       00 33 561 283 404
------------------------------------------------------------------
DOCUMENT NUMBER:   CCSDS 122.0-R-1        Red Book, Issue 1
DOCUMENT NAME:     Image Data Compression
DATE ISSUED:       August 2004
PAGE NUMBER:   4-18                PARAGRAPH NUMBER:  4.4
RID SHORT TITLE: 
------------------------------------------------------------------
_____ APPROVE (MEMBER)   _____ CONCUR (OBSERVER)   __x__ COMMENTS

DESCRIPTION OF REQUESTED CHANGE:  (Use From: "..." To "..." format)
>From "For code option identification, we use Table 4-1"
to  "For code option identification, we use Table 4-10"

------------------------------------------------------------------
CATEGORY OF REQUESTED CHANGE:
     Technical Fact ___    Recommended ___    Editorial _x_
NOTES:
TECHNICAL FACT:  Major technical change of sufficient magnitude as to
 render the Recommendation inaccurate and unacceptable if not
 corrected.  (Supporting analysis/rationale is essential.)
RECOMMENDED:  Change of a nature that would, if incorporated, produce
 a marked improvement in document quality and acceptance.
EDITORIAL:  Typographical or other factual error needing correction.
 (This type of change will be made without feedback to submitter.)
------------------------------------------------------------------
SUPPORTING ANALYSIS:





------------------------------------------------------------------
DISPOSITION:
-------------- next part --------------
                    REVIEW ITEM DISPOSITION (RID):
                    RED BOOK RID INITIATION FORM

AGENCY RID NUMBER:
SUBMITTING ORGANIZATION (Agency, Center):
------------------------------------------------------------------
REVIEWER'S NAME:   THIEBAUT	
CODE:              
E-MAIL ADDRESS:    carole.thiebaut at cnes.fr
TELEPHONE:       00 33 561 283 404
------------------------------------------------------------------
DOCUMENT NUMBER:   CCSDS 122.0-R-1        Red Book, Issue 1
DOCUMENT NAME:     Image Data Compression
DATE ISSUED:       August 2004
PAGE NUMBER:   4-19                PARAGRAPH NUMBER:  4.4
RID SHORT TITLE: 
------------------------------------------------------------------
_____ APPROVE (MEMBER)   _____ CONCUR (OBSERVER)   __x__ COMMENTS

DESCRIPTION OF REQUESTED CHANGE:  (Use From: "..." To "..." format)
>From "the same data format illustrated in Figures 4-7 and 4-8"
to  "the same data format illustrated in Figures 4-8 and 4-9"

------------------------------------------------------------------
CATEGORY OF REQUESTED CHANGE:
     Technical Fact ___    Recommended ___    Editorial _x_
NOTES:
TECHNICAL FACT:  Major technical change of sufficient magnitude as to
 render the Recommendation inaccurate and unacceptable if not
 corrected.  (Supporting analysis/rationale is essential.)
RECOMMENDED:  Change of a nature that would, if incorporated, produce
 a marked improvement in document quality and acceptance.
EDITORIAL:  Typographical or other factual error needing correction.
 (This type of change will be made without feedback to submitter.)
------------------------------------------------------------------
SUPPORTING ANALYSIS:





------------------------------------------------------------------
DISPOSITION:
-------------- next part --------------
                    REVIEW ITEM DISPOSITION (RID):
                    RED BOOK RID INITIATION FORM

AGENCY RID NUMBER:
SUBMITTING ORGANIZATION (Agency, Center):
------------------------------------------------------------------
REVIEWER'S NAME:   THIEBAUT	
CODE:              
E-MAIL ADDRESS:    carole.thiebaut at cnes.fr
TELEPHONE:       00 33 561 283 404
------------------------------------------------------------------
DOCUMENT NUMBER:   CCSDS 122.0-R-1        Red Book, Issue 1
DOCUMENT NAME:     Image Data Compression
DATE ISSUED:       August 2004
PAGE NUMBER:   4-23                PARAGRAPH NUMBER:  4.5.3.2
RID SHORT TITLE: Table 4-11 title
------------------------------------------------------------------
_____ APPROVE (MEMBER)   _____ CONCUR (OBSERVER)   __x__ COMMENTS

DESCRIPTION OF REQUESTED CHANGE:  (Use From: "..." To "..." format)
>From "Summary of Possible Word Values"
to  "Summary of Maximum Word Lengths and Impossible Values"

------------------------------------------------------------------
CATEGORY OF REQUESTED CHANGE:
     Technical Fact ___    Recommended ___    Editorial _x_
NOTES:
TECHNICAL FACT:  Major technical change of sufficient magnitude as to
 render the Recommendation inaccurate and unacceptable if not
 corrected.  (Supporting analysis/rationale is essential.)
RECOMMENDED:  Change of a nature that would, if incorporated, produce
 a marked improvement in document quality and acceptance.
EDITORIAL:  Typographical or other factual error needing correction.
 (This type of change will be made without feedback to submitter.)
------------------------------------------------------------------
SUPPORTING ANALYSIS:





------------------------------------------------------------------
DISPOSITION: