[Cesg-all] Results of CESG Polls closing 9 February 2023

[CCSDS Secretariat]

CESG E-Poll Identifier:  CESG-P-2023-01-002 Approval to publish CCSDS 130.11-G-2, SCCC—Summary of Definition and Performance (Green Book, Issue 2)

Results of CESG poll beginning 26 January 2023 and ending 9 February 2023:

                 Abstain:  1 (14.29%) (Duhaze)
 Approve Unconditionally:  5 (71.43%) (Barkley, Merri, Cola, Aguilar Sanchez, Wilmot)
 Approve with Conditions:  1 (14.29%) (Shames)
 Disapprove with Comment:  0 (0%)  

CONDITIONS/COMMENTS:

     Erik Barkley (Approve Unconditionally):  ​A minor comment, not a condition -- a suggestion for improved presentation re Figure 3-1 and 3-2: Perhaps a subgraph with a different scale could be considered – as presented for figure 3-1, all the blue lines are hard to distinguish. The main message is apparent but the distinctions among ACM13 - 17 tend to get lost. There is a similar consideration with regard to the orange lines in figure 3 – 2.  

     Peter Shames (Approve with Conditions):  ​This document makes heavy reference to the actual standard.  As such it is almost as if the reader needs to read the standard first, and then this "description",  I noted a numder of editorial changes for clarification in the body of the text.  They are for clarity and do not make any substantive changes to the body of the document.

     Jonathan Wilmot (Approve Unconditionally):  ​This book does read as though it was a user's guide for the standard. This is different than most Green books but I think it is reasonable to do it this way.


Total Respondents:  7

All Areas responded to this question.



SECRETARIAT INTERPRETATION OF RESULTS:  Approved with Conditions
PROPOSED SECRETARIAT ACTION:            Generate CMC poll after conditions have been addressed

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

CESG E-Poll Identifier:  CESG-P-2023-01-003 Approval to publish CCSDS 130.12-G-2, CCSDS Protocols over DVB-S2—Summary of Definition, Implementation, and Performance (Green Book, Issue 2)

Results of CESG poll beginning 26 January 2023 and ending 9 February 2023:

                 Abstain:  1 (14.29%) (Duhaze)
 Approve Unconditionally:  5 (71.43%) (Barkley, Merri, Cola, Aguilar Sanchez, Wilmot)
 Approve with Conditions:  1 (14.29%) (Shames)
 Disapprove with Comment:  0 (0%)  

CONDITIONS/COMMENTS:

     Peter Shames (Approve with Conditions):  There are some minor issues to be dealt with marked in the body of the text.  These are terminology and reference issues identified for clarity.  I will point out that the intro section of this document are far superior to those in 130.11.  


Total Respondents:  7

All Areas responded to this question.



SECRETARIAT INTERPRETATION OF RESULTS:  Approved with Conditions
PROPOSED SECRETARIAT ACTION:            Generate CMC poll after conditions have been addressed

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *