[Cesg-all] SANA Registry status

[John Garrett]

Hi Peter,

I think the version of the GSCID list that is out there is still the same one 
that was out there at the last meeting and was out of date then.  What was there 
was mostly reasonable, but the actual GSCID register is usually updated several 
times a month.  My understanding was that SANA operator would monitor the 
authoritative list and would update their lists on their site on a regular 
basis.  I still think it is sufficient for SANA to just point to the 
authoritative version.

See you next week when we can discuss this more.

Cheers,
-JOhn

On 5/12/2011 12:22 PM, Shames, Peter M (313B) wrote:
> John,
>
> This is all true and is what is documented in the SANA Yellow Book.  The SANA 
> has pointers to those registries, and it also has, in one searchable and 
> identifiable location, the information contained in those registries.  This is 
> as was agreed.
>
> Please take the time to review the SANA registries and ensure that all of the 
> information, including the pointers to the authoritative sources, is accurate. 
>  Then approve these registries so that they are listed in the Approved set.
>
> Thanks, Peter
>
>
> From: John Garrett <John.G.Garrett at nasa.gov <mailto:John.G.Garrett at nasa.gov>>
> Date: Thu, 12 May 2011 09:18:11 -0700
> To: Peter Shames <peter.m.shames at jpl.nasa.gov <mailto:peter.m.shames at jpl.nasa.gov>>
> Cc: CCSDS Engineering Steering Group - CESG All <cesg-all at mailman.ccsds.org 
> <mailto:cesg-all at mailman.ccsds.org>>, Mike Kearney <Mike.Kearney at nasa.gov 
> <mailto:Mike.Kearney at nasa.gov>>, "SANA Steering Group (SSG)" 
> <ssg at mailman.ccsds.org <mailto:ssg at mailman.ccsds.org>>
> Subject: Re: [Cesg-all] SANA Registry status
>
>     Hi Peter,
>
>     As was agreed when we created the SANA, a couple of the registries were
>     grandfathered in and NSSDC will continue to be the register for those.  The
>     SANA registry is supposed to point to those.
>
>     The two top-level registries grandfathered in are the Spacecraft ID
>     assignment and the Control Authority Office Assignments (including the
>     several different pieces that the single registry was broken up into, such
>     as Member Agency Control Authority Office Registry and Control Authority
>     Organization Contacts, etc.).
>
>     Cheers,
>     -JOhn
>
>     On 5/12/2011 11:20 AM, Shames, Peter M (313B) wrote:
>>     Dear CESG Colleagues,
>>
>>     During the last CCSDS working meetings in London we announced that the
>>     SANA operator was in place, that the SANA web site now exists
>>     (http://www.sanaregistry.org) and that there was a set of what we called
>>     "Candidate Registries" that had been created.  These candidate registries
>>     contain information culled from the existing Blue Books in each of your
>>     areas.  The purpose of the SANA, as you know, is to provide a single point
>>     of reference for all of the CCSDS managed numbers, namespaces, and XML
>>     schema.  A primary intent of the SANA is to provide "one stop shopping"
>>     for our users as to where to go looking for this information, and also to
>>     remove the need to produce a Blue Book update, with all of the review
>>     overhead that entails, in order to update some numbers in a table.
>>
>>     This is the list of candidate registries that are now on the web site:
>>
>>     Bundle Protocol Compressed Bundle Header Encoding Node Numbers
>>     <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/bp_cbhe_node_numbers>
>>     Bundle Protocol
>>     <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/bp_cbhe_service_numbers>Compressed Bundle
>>     Header Encoding Service Numbers
>>     <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/bp_cbhe_service_numbers>
>>     CCSDS File Delivery Protocol (CFDP) Entity Identifier
>>     <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/cfdp_entity_id>
>>     CCSDS Glossary <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/glossary>
>>     CCSDS Object Identifiers (OID) <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/oid>
>>     CLCW Version Number <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/clcw_version_number>
>>     Control Authority Organizations <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/cao>
>>     Control Authority Organizations Contacts
>>     <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/cao_contacts>
>>     Extended Protocol Identifiers
>>     <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/extended_protocol_id>
>>     Frame Secondary Header Version Number
>>     <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/frame_secondary_header_version_number>
>>     Internet Protocol Extension Header <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/ipe_header>
>>     Licklider Transmission Protocol Engine Identifiers
>>     <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/ltp_engineid>
>>     Licklider Transmission Protocol Service Identifiers
>>     <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/ltp_serviceid>
>>     MAP Identifier (MAP ID) <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/map_id>
>>     Member Agency Control Authority Office Registries
>>     <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/macao>
>>     Packet Version Number <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/packet_version_number>
>>     Port Identifier <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/port_id>
>>     Protocol Identifier <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/protocol_id>
>>     Radio Sources <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/radio_sources>
>>     SCPS-NP Domain Identifier (D-ID)
>>     <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/scps_np_domain_id>
>>     SCPS-NP End System Identifier (ES-ID)
>>     <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/scps_np_end_system_id>
>>     SCPS-NP Path Identifier (P-ID) <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/scps_np_path_id>
>>     SCPS-NP Transport Protocol Identifier (TP-ID)
>>     <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/scps_np_transport_protocol_id>
>>     SCPS-TP Connection Identifier
>>     <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/scps_tp_connection_id>
>>     Space Agencies <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/agencies>
>>     Spacecraft Identifiers <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/spacecraftid>
>>     Space Link Identifiers Registries
>>     <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/space_link_id>
>>     Space Packet Protocol Application
>>     <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/space_packet_protocol_application_process_id>
>>     Process Identifier(APID)
>>     <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/space_packet_protocol_application_process_id>
>>     Transfer Frame Version Number
>>     <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/transfer_frame_version_number>
>>     Virtual Channel Identifier (VCID)
>>     <http://www.sanaregistry.org/c/virtual_channel_id>
>>
>>     The SANA operator has done the hard work of combing the CCSDS documents to
>>     identify those items that should be registered and creating these
>>     candidate registries.  It is the assigned task of the Area Directors and
>>     individual working groups to review these for accuracy and to approve them
>>     for release on the SANA web site.  It will eventually be necessary to
>>     provide some sort of WG policy statement as to how these registries are to
>>     be managed, but that is less important at this point than reviewing and
>>     approving the registries.
>>
>>     And please note, of all of the registries that were identified since last
>>     fall only one (1) is now an Approved Registry.  That is the:
>>
>>     Navigation Data Messages XML Schema <http://www.sanaregistry.org/r/ndmxml>
>>
>>     Go take a look at this (just click on the link) to see a good example of
>>     how an XML schema registry may be organized.    The XML schema that have
>>     been standardized in MOIMS SM&C, CSS SM, and MOIMS XFDU should be
>>     similarly documented and registered.  This is a task that these working
>>     groups will have to take up, but the SANA operator will provide
>>     assistance.  At a minimum at least the whole schema should be registered
>>     so that our users can reference them in one well identified, easy to find,
>>     on-line, repository.
>>
>>     Please take some time during this coming week of working meetings to at
>>     least go look at these candidate registries and make some assignments to
>>     get them reviewed and approved by the working group.  It is important to
>>     get this done and it is your responsibility.
>>
>>     Best regards, Peter
>>
>>     ________________________________________________________
>>
>>     Peter Shames
>>     CCSDS System Engineering Area Director
>>
>>     Jet Propulsion Laboratory, MS 301-490
>>     California Institute of Technology
>>     Pasadena, CA 91109 USA
>>
>>     Telephone: +1 818 354-5740,  Fax: +1 818 393-6871
>>
>>     Internet: Peter.M.Shames at jpl.nasa.gov
>>     ________________________________________________________
>>
>>     We must recognize the strong and undeniable influence that our language
>>     exerts on our ways of thinking and, in fact, delimits the abstract space
>>     in which we can formulate - give form to - our thoughts.
>>
>>     Niklaus Wirth
>>
>>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://mailman.ccsds.org/pipermail/cesg-all/attachments/20110512/e6f7142a/attachment.htm